By Dan Wilson, Co-Founder and Chief Data Officer, Charlie Oscar
Creator content is often thrown into campaigns alongside brand or agency-built assets, tasked with delivering a CPA. Sometimes winning, sometimes losing. Optimised up or down based on platform CPA, with little insight into how it actually performs differently for the business.
But the real value from this content comes in the data points you probably don’t see. What they do to incrementality, how they change the audience your campaigns get served to, and how they change how social campaigns impact activity on other platforms.
When you understand this data, you can drive huge uplifts in business impact of creator assets. Sometimes even when the platform CPA is unchanged.
Creator ads (e.g. Partnership Ads on Meta, or Spark Ads on TikTok) are not simply another paid social format. They change the way the algorithm interprets signals, identifies audiences, and ultimately delivers performance. While most creator content continues to be seen as a creative variation, it should instead be seen as a data signal.
Partnership ads change how the algorithm works
Partnership ads are influencer content amplified through paid channels: creator posts boosted directly from the creator’s account or cross-posted as paid social creative. The content carries the creator’s identity, not just the brand’s (sometimes it is the creator only, sometimes it is both the creator and the brand). Audiences respond to it differently to standard brand ads, and that changes both who it is served to and how they behave when the ad is served to them.
Most paid social campaigns rely entirely on a brand’s own data to guide delivery.
Partnership ads work differently, because the platform can use both the brand’s signals and the creator’s audience signals when deciding who is most likely to respond. Instead of only reaching people the algorithm already associates with your business, partnership ads can introduce your brand to audiences that would otherwise remain outside your usual targeting pool.
Meta studies show that 66% of users reached by partnership ads were not reached by standard campaigns, even when budgets, targeting and optimisation remained the same. That is not simply a creative improvement; it is a change in how the platform finds people to serve your ads to.
What the data shows
One of the biggest mistakes brands make is judging partnership ads only through platform reporting. Ads Manager can show attribution, but it does not always show true incrementality. When Charlie Oscar looked at performance through marketing mix modelling, in research we ran with Meta across 94 studies, the difference became much clearer.
Partnership ads delivered:
- 30% more incremental conversions per pound spent
- 2.6x more incremental orders per impression
- A 50% higher share of new customer acquisition
Even after creator fees and production costs were included, partnership ads consistently outperformed standard paid social activity. The strongest value often sits in the conversions that would not have happened without them.
We presented the full research at Meta Marketing Summit UK: Creator Edition, covering how to balance incrementality, reach expansion and cross-channel impact in live campaigns.
The impact goes beyond social
Partnership ads do not only improve results inside Meta. People do not move through channels in isolation; they may discover a brand through a creator, then later return through search, direct traffic or another channel.
That wider influence can be difficult to see inside platform dashboards, but the modelling showed that partnership ads generated 125% stronger search synergy than standard paid social campaigns, and double the impact on incremental brand searches. That matters because brand search demand is one of the clearest signals of genuine audience interest, and one of the strongest predictors of long-term commercial return.
Why most brands are not using creator ads to their full potential
The most common reason for brands not getting the most from creator ads is structural. Influencer and paid media sit in separate teams, sometimes in separate agencies, with separate briefs and separate reporting.
The influencer team manages creator relationships, content production and organic performance. The paid team manages creative, targeting and conversion. When influencer content performs well, the insight stays in the influencer report. The paid team is not briefed to amplify it because workflows do not connect the two.
The second reason is measurement. Most brands do not have a framework that distinguishes the incremental impact of creator assets vs brand assets. Without that distinction, the benefit of partnership ads is invisible in the reporting, which makes it hard to justify the operational change required to use them systematically.
What advertisers should do next
1. Pick creators for the signals they unlock. The creator matters, but not simply because they produce good content. The real value comes from the audience signals they unlock and the way those signals help the algorithm work harder for your brand. Smaller creators can often outperform larger ones, because highly engaged audiences can be more valuable than scale alone.
2. Connect influencer and paid. The paid team needs to know which influencer content is generating the strongest commercial signals in near-real-time, not in the monthly wrap report. Creator performance data needs to inform amplification decisions while the content is still relevant.
3. Amplify on commercial signals, not engagement. Content generating strong brand search demand signals is worth amplifying. Content generating high engagement but no commercial signal is not.
4. Use partnership ads across the funnel. At the upper funnel, partnership ads extend the reach of the organic content building brand awareness. Creator content reaching an audience of 100,000 organically can reach multiples of that through paid distribution, without losing
the authenticity that makes it work. At the lower funnel, UGC-style short-form content amplified to audiences primed by that earlier exposure consistently outperforms standard ad creative. Our analysis shows UGC influencer creative performs 25% better than standard ad campaigns.
5. Measure both direct and indirect effects. Direct effects, such as conversions, click-through rates and cost per acquisition, are measurable through standard paid media tracking. Indirect effects, such as brand search demand, improvements in paid media efficiency across other channels and long-term brand equity, require marketing mix modelling.
What good looks like
Influencer content goes live. The paid team has visibility of performance data as it comes in. Content generating strong commercial signals (brand search uplift, paid media efficiency improvements, direct conversion) is identified and moved into paid amplification within the campaign window. The creative that performs best organically becomes the creative that reaches the widest paid audience.
The result is a compounding effect: organic reach builds awareness and generates brand search demand; paid amplification converts that demand more efficiently than standard creative. The improved paid efficiency generates data that informs the next organic brief, and each campaign cycle produces better inputs for the next.
The amplification gap
Influencer marketing and paid social are usually managed as separate investments. Partnership ads are the mechanism that makes them one.
The brands seeing the strongest results are not just creating better ads. They are feeding better signals into the platform. Brands that do not are paying for two separate campaigns when the better-performing one is already sitting in the influencer report.
Read more on creator economy effectiveness on Creator Age, or sign up to receive our weekly newsletter.







